TwelvestoneDesign

Quick Ad Critique Please


Sign in

  • Waiting for Godot ( 730 k posts )
    Just conversation.
  • Thunder Dome ( 23 k posts )
    Photoshop Tennis and Collabs.
  • Photography ( 5.1 k posts )
    For all you shutterbugs, sh...
  • Flash ( 18 k posts )
    ActionScripting to tweens, ...
  • Front End ( 5.9 k posts )
    general front end design an...
  • Back End ( 9.7 k posts )
    serverside scripting, progr...
  • Projects and Theory ( 12 k posts )
    This forum is for discussio...
  • FAQ ( 269 posts )
    All those nagging questions...
  • Design ( 17 k posts )
    graphics & all aspects of g...
  • Purgatory ( 3.6 k posts )
    12stone Jail, feel free to ...
Media44
 
2011-10-20

This is an ad for one of the directories I work for. Just looking for some quick comments on whether you think it is good as is or what could be improved upon. The stock photo has already been requested by the powers above my office.

Gulf Coast Ad

jestros
 
2011-10-20

I'm not digging the red font. I would try some more standard, less hip sans serif options.

rogue_designer
 
2011-10-20

Too many mixed typefaces (or not enough differentiation between them to bother with a second typeface).

Colorwise - it probably makes more sense to better leverage the blue or the yellow, rather than introducing a new color, to my eyes... works better with their branding.

Also, the right hand content is getting buried.

Third - I think that dude has his ladder backwards.

FlamingoJeff
 
2011-10-20

true about the ladder.

Nat
 
2011-10-20

Are you writing the ad too? If so, I'd change the headline to "Are your customers in reach?" and then "Bring them closer with Marine Yellow Pages". Two 'your's in the headline bugs me.

The design doesn't grab me either - i'd use a solid yellow or blue for the background - either full bleed or make a panel full width for the logo/contact info, deepetch the guy on the ladder and photoshop the top of the ladder so it looks like one simple ladder rather than an extension.

One typeface for the head and copy too - bold for the head, watch the kerning and a light weight for the body. Ditch the helvetica extended - it looks like you're trying to make the small amount of copy take up too much space for mine.

Also, can you lose the keyline around Yellow Pages on the logo? It looks cheap. Using a solid bg behind that panel night help with that.

Sorry for the harsh critique mate. I think you can do better k

Media44
 
2011-10-21

Lol good stuff. I didnt want to sway the comments but I had no part in that ad. My boss saw the one I did (below), called me into his office and told me it was no good and that I need to use more modern fonts instead of relying on sans serifs so much. Then he handed me that one which he did.. I think its crap and really want to make at least changes to that Are Your part and some horizontal element behind the bullets... And remove the actual bullets since they aren't aligned. He did request the photo from our parent company in ny but they haven't sent it yet, maybe if I point out the ladder being backwards that will put an end to this awful ad.

Heres what I had done, I especially like that nats wording is exactly what I did.

clean gulf 2

Media44
 
2011-10-21

Well brought it up with him. He didn't care about the ladder being backwards so then I just asked if I could make some changes. He asked like what and I said just some minor stuff to the text. He said no. Then he called me back in a minute later and said if I made minor changes he'd be open to at least look at them.

This is what I'm going to propose. Its at least better than that red crap heading he had. Of course gotta see if he goes for it. At least I know I'm not crazy thanks to this thread.

Clean Gulf

rogue_designer
 
2011-10-21

Yah, that's much better - I was thinking something like this, if you needed to salvage the art/concept/language

reach alt

Sorry, you must be a member to post to a conversation. Either log in or sign up to get involved.
TwelvestoneDesign

Quick Ad Critique Please